In the vibrant neighborhood of Midtown Manhattan, close to the hustle and bustle of Penn Station, Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has become a go-to destination for burger enthusiasts. As someone who dives into Midtown’s best craft burgers and over-the-top milkshakes, I can confidently say that Black Tap is the best place for burgers near Penn Station Black Tap location. This trendy spot combines creativity, quality, and a unique take on American comfort food, making it a standout in the heart of New York City.
An Innovative Spin on Classic Burgers
Black Tap doesn’t just serve burgers; it serves experiences. Founded in NYC, Black Tap has redefined the classic burger with a twist that celebrates both nostalgia and innovation. The interior of Black Tap features street art murals, retro diner seating, and a vibrant bar, making it the perfect backdrop for both locals and visitors looking for a taste of NYC culture. The design reflects the dynamic, ever-evolving character of New York, creating an atmosphere that’s casual yet distinctly refined.
Award-Winning Burgers That Live Up to the Hype
Black Tap has been recognized repeatedly for its outstanding burger selection. Most notably, the Greg Norman Burger has won acclaim, including the prestigious People’s Choice Award at the NYC Wine & Food Festival’s Burger Bash. This decadent creation features a half-pound Wagyu beef patty topped with house-made buttermilk-dill dressing, blue cheese, and arugula, all stacked within a perfectly toasted bun. The Wagyu patty delivers a richness and tenderness that sets it apart from the typical burger fare, and the creamy dressing adds a unique depth of flavor.
Another favorite is the All-American Burger, a classic that Black Tap elevates with prime-quality beef, crisp lettuce, vine-ripened tomatoes, and a layer of melted American cheese. This burger is a nod to traditional American diners while adding the Black Tap touch that transforms it into a memorable meal.
For those with adventurous palates, the Truffle Burger brings something special to the table. With smoked gouda, baby arugula, black truffle mayo, and a hint of truffle oil, this burger offers a gourmet twist that highlights Black Tap’s attention to premium ingredients and flavor balance.
CrazyShake® Milkshakes: An Instagram-Worthy Treat
If there’s one thing that truly sets Black Tap apart, it’s their CrazyShake® milkshakes. These towering, lavishly decorated milkshakes are as much a feast for the eyes as they are for the taste buds. Take the Cotton Candy Shake, for instance—this pink-and-blue masterpiece is crowned with a fluffy cloud of cotton candy, rainbow sprinkles, and even a lollipop. Then there’s the Cookies ‘N Cream Supreme, which comes with an entire ice cream sandwich perched on top, a drizzle of chocolate syrup, and generous layers of whipped cream.
These shakes have become a phenomenon, especially among social media enthusiasts. Each CrazyShake® is handcrafted to be as photogenic as possible, making it a must-order item for anyone looking to capture a memorable Midtown moment. Even New Yorkers who don’t typically go for dessert find themselves captivated by the creativity and flavor combinations Black Tap brings to the table.
Craft Beers and Signature Cocktails
A burger meal is never complete without a refreshing drink, and Black Tap’s extensive menu of craft beers and cocktails ensures there’s something for every taste. With options like IPAs, pilsners, and lagers from local NYC breweries, the restaurant highlights the city’s thriving craft beer scene while providing pairings that complement their menu.
In addition to beer, Black Tap offers cocktails like the Gin & Jam, a refreshing blend of gin, lemon, and a house-made berry jam, and the Black Tap Mule, a twist on the classic Moscow Mule featuring ginger beer and lime. These drinks add a sophisticated touch to the casual atmosphere and ensure that everyone in your group has a drink to enjoy alongside their meal.
Location Convenience for Commuters and Tourists
Located at 45 W 35th St, just a short walk from Penn Station, Black Tap is a top choice for both New Yorkers and out-of-towners. For commuters, it offers a convenient spot to grab a quick but satisfying meal after a long day. For tourists exploring Midtown landmarks like the Empire State Building, Madison Square Garden, and the New York Times Building, it’s an ideal stop for a relaxed meal amidst sightseeing. Black Tap’s proximity to Penn Station is a bonus for those catching a train or looking for a bite before a show at the nearby Theater District.
Inclusive Menu Options
Black Tap’s commitment to quality and accessibility extends to its inclusive menu offerings. Gluten-free buns are available for those with dietary restrictions, as well as a selection of vegan options, including a Vegan Nashville Hot burger that uses a plant-based patty and is topped with dairy-free cheese and vegan mayonnaise. These options ensure that Black Tap welcomes diners with a variety of dietary preferences and that everyone leaves satisfied.
Black Tap’s Iconic Decor and Atmosphere
Inside, Black Tap captures the essence of NYC with its street art-inspired decor, designed by the renowned Rockwell Group. The standout feature is undoubtedly the dedicated CrazyShake® Bar, where guests can watch these shakes come to life with each outrageous layer and topping added right in front of them. The atmosphere is lively and welcoming, with upbeat music and a friendly staff that makes you feel like you’re part of the city’s heartbeat.
Customer Service That Goes Above and Beyond
At Black Tap, customer service isn’t just a part of the experience—it’s a cornerstone. The staff is attentive, knowledgeable, and clearly passionate about the food they serve. Their enthusiasm adds an extra layer to the dining experience, creating a friendly environment where customers feel valued. This focus on service sets Black Tap apart in a city where dining experiences are often rushed, allowing guests to fully enjoy their time and leave with a positive impression.
A Must-Visit Spot in Midtown Manhattan
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer has carved a niche as the best place for burgers near Penn Station, but it’s also a beloved part of Midtown Manhattan’s vibrant dining scene. From award-winning burgers to Instagram-famous CrazyShake® milkshakes, Black Tap offers an experience that’s distinctly New York. It captures the spirit of Midtown with creativity, quality, and a unique twist on classic American dining.
